Skip to main content
Engineering LibreTexts

10.1.1: 1 Natural Ecosystem and Agroecosystem Comparison

  • Page ID
    48517
  • Pest species can be present in agroecosystems, but not cause significant crop yield loss or livestock productivity reductions. Why? What factors prevent pest populations from reducing yield? One explanation may be that the crop or livestock is resistant to the pest. For instance, a crop plant may produce compounds that fend off pathogen infection or deter insect feeding. And if environmental conditions and resources are ideal, the plant may be able to grow and recover from pest infestation. What other ecological processes and factors might contribute to agricultural resilience to pests or other stresses such as climate change?

    Activate Your Learning

    Question 1 - Short Answer

    Draw a food web pyramid and label the trophic levels as categories of organisms with i. primary producers at the bottom, ii. herbivores next, ii. omnivores and carnivores at the top of the pyramid. Chose a natural ecosystem and list all of the species you can think of that are found at each trophic level in the natural ecosystem. Then draw a second food web pyramid for a type of farm that you are familiar with, and list all of the species you might find at each trophic level. Describe how your the natural ecosystem and the agroecosystem compare. How do they differ?

    (add text box)

    Click for answer

    Answer:
    You should have many more species at each trophic level in the natural ecosystem. Additionally, the genetic diversity within species in the natural ecosystem is typically greater than in the agroecosystem.

    Question 2 - Short Answer

    Odum (1997), an Ecologist summarized some of the major functional differences between natural and agroecosystems that are shown in the table below. Consider how your natural and agroecosystem food pyramids offer examples of the below ecosystem differences. How many predatory and parasitic species are there in the natural ecosystem and agroecosystem? How might the presence of predatory and parasitic organisms impact agricultural pests? How might genetic diversity contribute to pest management and ecosystem stability?

    (add text box)

    Click for answer

    Answer:
    Although you may not be familiar with parasitic species such as wasps and nematodes, you likely can think of many predatory species: humans, large and small mammals, predatory birds, rodents, fish, and arthropods (ex. beetles, spiders, ants, etc.)

    In natural ecosystems there tend to be more niches and a higher diversity of species compared to most managed agroecosystems that are simpler, have fewer predatory and parasitic species, and less genetic diversity within a species. As the table below indicates with fewer trophic interactions, there are fewer species to reduce pest populations and prevent them from reducing agricultural yield and quality. Further, with low genetic diversity within agricultural species and across the landscape, the agricultural system is more vulnerable to pest outbreaks than natural ecosystems.

    Natural Ecosystems and Agroecosystems
    Property Natural Ecosystem Agroecosystems
    Human Control Low High
    Net Productivity Medium High
    Species and Genetic Diversity High Low
    Trophic Interactions Complex Simple, Linear
    Habitat Heterogeneity Complex Simple
    Nutrient Cycles Closed Open
    Stability (resilience) High Low
    • Was this article helpful?