Skip to main content
Engineering LibreTexts

2.8: TRILL and SPB

  • Page ID
  • As Ethernets get larger, the spanning-tree algorithm becomes more and more a problem, primarily because useful links are disabled and redundancy is lost. In a high-performance network, such as within a datacenter, disabled links are a wasted resource. A secondary issue is that, in the event of link failure, the spanning-tree approach can take many seconds to create a new tree and restore connectivity.

    To address these problems, there are now protocols which allow Ethernet to have active loops in the topology, making first-class use of all links. The idea is to generate forwarding tables within the Ethernet switches – or at least within some of them – that route every packet along the shortest path – or at least an approximation to the shortest path – based on all available links. This has long been a staple in the IP world (9 Routing-Update Algorithms), but is definitely a break with tradition at the LAN layer.

    There are two competing protocols here: TRILL (TRansparent Interconnection of Lots of Links) and SPB (Shortest-Path Bridging). TRILL is documented in [RP04] and RFC 6325 [] and companions, while SPB is standardized by IEEE 802.1aq []. We will focus here on TRILL.

    Both TRILL and SPB envision that, initially, only a few switches will be smart enough to do shortest-path routing, just as, once upon a time, only a few switches implemented the spanning-tree algorithm. But, with time, it is likely that eventually most if not all Ethernet switches will be shortest-path aware. In high-performance datacenters it is particularly likely that forwarding will be based on TRILL or SPB.

    In TRILL, the Ethernet switches that are TRILL-aware are known as Router-Bridges, or RBridges (the terms RSwitches and TRILL Switches might also be appropriate). In between the RBridges are Legacy Ethernets (called “links” in [RP04] and RFC 6325 [], though this term is misleading); Legacy Ethernets consist of maximal subnetworks of Ethernet hosts and non-TRILL-aware switches. The intent is for the RBridges to partition the entire Ethernet into relatively small Legacy Ethernets. In the ultimate case where all switches are RBridges, the Legacy Ethernets are simply individual hosts. In the diagram below, four RBridges isolate Legacy Ethernets 1, 2, 3 and 4, though Legacy Ethernet 5 represents a degree of partitioning inefficiency.


    Each Legacy Ethernet elects a single connected RBridge to represent it. There is a unique choice for LE1 through LE4 above, but LE5 must make a decision. This elected RBridge is known as the Designated RBridge, or DRB. Each Legacy Ethernet then builds its own spanning tree, perhaps (though not necessarily) rooted at its Designated RBridge.

    Traffic from a Legacy Ethernet to the outside will generally be forwarded through its Designated RBridge; connections to other RBridges will not be used. The idea is for packets from one Legacy Ethernet to another to be delivered first to the source node’s DRB, and then to the destination node’s DRB via true shortest-path forwarding between the RBridges, and from there to the destination node. Of course, in the ultimate case where every switch is an RBridge, traffic will take the shortest path from start to finish.

    The one exception to this rule about forwarding through the Designated RBridge is that the DRB can delegate this forwarding task to other RBridges for different VLANs within the Legacy Ethernet. If this is done, each VLAN will always use the same RBridge for all its outside traffic.

    The second part of the process is for the RBridges each to figure out the overall topology; that is, each builds a complete map of all the RBridges and their interconnections. This is done using a link-state routing-update protocol, described in 9.5 Link-State Routing-Update Algorithm. Of the two primary link-state protocols, IS-IS and OSPF, TRILL has selected the former, as it is more easily adapted to a setting in which, as here, nodes do not necessarily have IP addresses. The RBridges each send out appropriate “link-state packets”, using multicast and using per-RBridge databases to ensure that these packets are not re-forwarded endlessly. These link-state packets can be compared to spanning-tree Hello messages. As is fundamental to link-state forwarding, once each RBridge has a complete map of all the RBridges, each RBridge can calculate an optimal route to any other RBridge.

    As Designated RBridges see packets from their Legacy Ethernets, they learn the MAC addresses of the active hosts within, via the usual Ethernet learning protocol. They then share these addresses with other RBridges, using the IS-IS link-state protocol, so other RBridges eventually learn how to reach most if not all Ethernet addresses present in the overall network.

    Delivery still must make use of fallback-to-flooding, however, to deliver to previously unknown destinations. To this end, the RBridges negotiate among themselves a spanning tree covering all the RBridges. Any packet with unknown destination is flooded along this spanning tree, and then, as the packet reaches a Designated RBridge for a Legacy Ethernet, is flooded along the spanning tree of that Ethernet. This process is also used for delivery of broadcast and multicast packets.

    As RBridges talk to one another, they negotiate compact two-byte addresses – known as “nicknames” – for one another, versus the standard Ethernet six-byte addresses. This saves space in the RBridge-to-RBridge communications.

    As packets travel between RBridges, a special TRILL header is added. This header includes a hopcount field, otherwise not present in Ethernet, which means any packets caught in transient routing loops will eventually be discarded. IS-IS may occasionally generate such routing loops, though they are rare.

    The TRILL header also includes the nicknames of the source and destination RBridges. This means that actual packet forwarding between RBridges does not involve the MAC address of the destination host; that is used only after the packet has reached the Designated RBridge for the destination Legacy Ethernet, at which point the TRILL header is removed.

    If a link between two RBridges fails, then the link’s endpoints send out IS-IS update messages to notify all the other RBridges of the failure. The other RBridges can then recalculate their forwarding tables so as not to use the broken link. Recovery time is typically under 0.1 seconds, a roughly hundredfold improvement over spanning-tree recovery times.

    TRILL supports the use of multiple equal-cost paths to improve throughput between two RBridges; cf 9.7 ECMP. In a high-performance datacenter, this feature is very important.

    Like TRILL, SPB uses IS-IS between the SPB-aware bridges to find shortest paths, and encapsulates packets with a special header as they travel between RBridges. SPB does not include a hopcount in the encapsulation header; instead, it more carefully controls forwarding. SPB also uses the original destination MAC address for inter-RBridge forwarding.